Wednesday, June 9, 2010

Debunking the Predator Argument

One of objections to backyard chickens is the fear that they will increase the number of obnoxious opossums, raccoons, and rats.

The increased predator concern is common, predictable and irrational. Every neighborhood in Sarasota is crawling at night with raccoons, roof (black) rats, opossums, etc. They are eating garbage in garbage cans, cat food left outdoors, fallen fruit, and "compost" that is little more than people dumping food scraps outside in a pile. Raccoons work over fish ponds, pulling out fish and tadpoles. Some people actually leave food out for the raccoons, which can carry rabies. If you don't believe rats are already omnipresent, take a walk around any mall and you're likely to see numerous black plastic rat traps that proliferate without any chickens to support them.

Most people are blissfully unaware of all this wild nightlife, and if they were, they would probably try to forget. The point is most neighbors have little awareness of and no inclination to do anything about these night-time omnivores.

Chicken keepers, on the other hand, are passionately motivated to monitor and manage these animals, which once they learn about a food source keep coming back. C.L.U.C.K. is committed to providing prospective chicken-keepers with information about predator-resistant coops, but people who take shortcuts will quickly learn about any shortcomings of their coop design and they will be the people live-trapping predators and calling animal control to come pick them up at $20 a pop.

Yes, it costs $20 to have animal control come pick up a live-trapped animal. Expensive, but there are two reasons why chicken keepers go with live trapping. First, it is the humane thing to do -- secondly, it is a low risk strategy if you catch the wrong target species.

Six chickens is not going to support a population of raccoons for very long, and after the first hen goes, the owner will be obsessively on the case to protect the remaining birds. It can be argued that the best way to reduce night predators would be to increase the number of people keeping chickens.

Snakes are similar, but generally more of a daytime issue. Like the rats, raccoons and opossums, they are already out there. No native snake is going to bother anything larger than a pullet. The notion that the snake population will measurably increase as a result of neighborhood chickens is another misplaced concern.

If you want some advice about local coop design, write to sarasotacluck at gmail.com for a draft document.


Chickens in....... Lakewood Ranch!?

City of Sarasota residents who want their children to have a better idea where food comes from will soon be able to drive to Lakewood Ranch to see a hen house. According to a recent Sarasota Herald Tribune article, Lakewood Ranch is adding a community "SmartFarm" at the entrance to a Pat Neal residential development and the farm will include a hen house.

We didn't see that coming.

While one Smartfarm is not the same as allowing chickens at Lakewood Ranch homes, it reflects an awareness of local food initiatives we have not seen here in the City.

Thursday, December 24, 2009

End of Year Report

CLUCK has been clucking along for about a half year now and its time for a status report.


3 • Number of online Sarasota CLUCK resources (BLOG • WEBPAGE • FACEBOOK GROUP)

3 • Minimum number of other groups that independently chose CLUCK for their chicken advocacy acronym

9 • Number of newspaper articles dealing with backyard chickens in Sarasota

24 • Number of CLUCK blog entries

40 • Percent of City Commissioners that wanted staff to work on backyard hen legalization

66 • Percent of City Commissioners needed to direct staff to work on legalizing backyard hens

116 • Number of local supporters on our email list

386 • Number of members in our FACEBOOK Group

665 • Number of times people have clicked on Sarasota CLUCK blog link on Sarasota Speaks

46,000 • Number of registered users on Backyard Chickens website

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Friday, December 11, 2009

Next meeting Weds Dec 16 Selby Library

We'll be meeting at the downtown Sarasota Selby Library this Wednesday at 6:00 p.m. We meet upstairs in a meeting room on the east side of the building. We'll review what's been happening, particularly the recent City Commission discussion, and discuss future strategy.

Monday, December 7, 2009

Backyard Chicken Disease Risk in Perspective

A concerned citizen recently wrote to a Sarasota City Commissioner opposing chickens as pets and citing six diseases that might be transmitted from chickens to humans as a reason.

Certainly all citizens should be concerned about the possible transfer of diseases from pets, livestock and wild animals to humans. Awareness has been growing regarding the importance of hand-washing after contact with any animal, including animals such as reptiles and fish.

The diseases cited in the email were:

Avian Tuberculosis: A tuberculosis that affects poultry. Main risk is to immune compromised individuals. According to the International Parrot Society People with normally functioning immune systems have a high resistance to this infection. The bacteria are already in the environment due to shedding from wildlife. However, we do urge at risk individuals to take proper precautions and avoid contact or exposure.

Chlamydiosis causes pitt or parrot fever. According to IFAS In the U.S., chlamydiosis is a major problem with turkeys, pigeons, and psittacines. In Europe, the main avian species affected are ducks and geese. Some birds (turkeys) are extremely susceptible to chlamydiosis, while others (chickens) are more resistant.

Colibacillosis is caused by E. coli, of which there are many strains. According to IFAS: In most cases, symptomatic treatment (fluids, antidiarrheals) is all that is required. In more severe infections, antibiotics such as tetracycline and chloramphenicol may be necessary.

Histoplasmosis is a fungal disease. According to IFAS Most cases in humans are asymptomatic, but it can be a serious disease.

Cryptococcosis is another fungal disease. Again In people with a normal immune system, the lung (pulmonary) form of the infection may have no symptoms. In people with impaired immune systems, the cryptococcus organism may spread to the brain.

Cryptosporidiosis according to IFAS Cryptosporidiosis is caused by protozoa of the genus Cryptosporidium . There are three known species, C. baileyi , C. meleagridis and an unnamed species in quail. Cryptosporidiosis normally causes respiratory problems in chickens and turkeys. It can also cause gastroenteritis and diarrhea. In humans, it causes abdominal pain, nausea, and watery diarrhea lasting 3-4 days. In immunocompromised people, it can cause severe, persistent diarrhea with associated malabsorption of nutrients and weight loss.

In addition to the diseases the citizen mentioned , Salmonella is probably the most common disease spread by pets like chickens, reptiles and fish. The CDC is particularly cautious about children under three handling (playing with) baby chicks.

For specific advice from the CDC please see Health Risks Associated With Raising Chickens.

To put all these diseases in perspective, it is worth considering how the CDC summarizes the number of diseases that can be transmitted from animals to people.

Under birds, the CDC lists three diseases, already mentioned above:

Chlamydia psittaci Infection (psittacosis): A bacterial disease associated with pet birds, including parrots and parakeets. Recommendations and Reports MMWR.

Cryptococcus Infection (cryptococcosis): A fungal disease associated with wild-bird droppings, including those from pigeons.

Salmonella Infection (salmonellosis): A bacterial disease associated with many birds, especially chickens, baby chicks, and ducklings.

For dogs, far more diseases are listed : 15 and for cats: 14. Because dogs and cats are mammals, and probably because of their long association with people, we share more diseases with them.

Bottom line: If we were allowing people to have pets based on diseases, cats and dogs would be near the end of the list. But that doesn’t eliminate possible problems with chickens.

CLUCK supports proper sanitation for the health of both chickens and chicken keepers. Young children and people with compromised immune systems are the greatest at risk. Handwashing after contact with all animals is recommended for everyone and people at greater risk should probably consider respiratory masks. At the end of this entry you'll find the 12 steps the CDC recommends to minimize risk. Virtually all are simple common sense and hygiene.

Below, you can learn the names of dog-related diseases.

Brucella canis Infection (brucellosis): A bacterial disease rarely associated with dogs.

Campylobacter Infection (campylobacteriosis): A bacterial disease associated with dogs, cats, and farm animals.

Cryptosporidium Infection (cryptosporidiosis): A parasitic disease associated with dogs, especially puppies, cats, and farm animals.

Dipylidium Infection (tapeworm): A parasitic disease associated with dogs, cats and fleas.

Giardia Infection (giardiasis): A parasitic disease associated with various animals, including dogs and their environment (including water).

Hookworm Infection: A parasitic disease associated with dogs and cats and their environment.

Leishmania Infection (leishmaniasis): A parasitic disease associated with dogs and sand flies outside the United States.

Leptospira Infection (leptospirosis): A bacterial disease associated with wild and domestic animals, including dogs.

Lyme Disease: A bacterial disease that can affect dogs and ticks.

Q Fever (Coxiella burnetii): A bacterial disease occasionally associated with dogs.

Rabies: A viral disease associated with various animals, including dogs.

Ringworm: A fungal disease associated with dogs.

Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever: A bacterial disease associated with dogs and ticks.

Roundworm: See Toxocara infection.

Salmonella Infection (salmonellosis): A bacterial disease associated with various animals including dogs.

Tapeworm (flea tapeworm): See Dipylidium Infection.

Toxocara Infection (toxocariasis, roundworm): A parasitic disease associated with dogs and cats and their environment.

The following list deals with diseases associated with cats.

Campylobacter Infection (campylobacteriosis): A bacterial disease associated with cats, dogs, and farm animals.

Cat Scratch Disease (Bartonella henselae): A bacterial disease associated with cat scratches and bites.

Coxiella burnetti Infection (Q fever): A bacterial disease occasionally associated with cats.

Cryptosporidium Infection (cryptosporidiosis): A parasitic disease associated with cats, dogs, and farm animals.

Dipylidium Infection (tapeworm): A parasitic disease associated with cats, dogs and fleas.

Hookworm Infection: A parasitic disease associated with cats, dogs and their environment.

Leptospira Infection (leptospirosis): A bacterial disease associated wild and domestic animals including cats.

Plague (Yersinia pestis) Infection: A rare bacterial disease associated with rodents and cats and fleas.

Q Fever (Coxiella burnetii): A bacterial disease occasionally associated with cats.

Rabies: A viral disease associated with various animals, including cats.

Ringworm: A fungal disease associated various animals, including with cats.

Roundworm: See Toxocara Infection.

Salmonella Infection (salmonellosis): A bacterial disease associated with various animals, including cats.

Tapeworm (flea tapeworm): See Dipylidium Infection.

Toxocara Infection (toxocariasis, roundworm): A parasitic disease associated with cats, dogs and their environment.

Toxoplasma Infection (toxoplasmosis): A parasitic disease associated with cats and their environment.

Listed below are the 12 steps the CDC recommends to minimize risk. Virtually all are simple common sense and hygiene.

1. Keep baby chicks and adult chickens away from persons with weaker immune

systems, including the elderly, pregnant women, diabetics, patients receiving

chemotherapy, and people who are infected with HIV.

2. Do not keep chickens if a household has children less than five years of age.

3. Make sure that any interaction between chicks or chickens and small children is

supervised and that children wash their hands afterwards. Children less than five

years of age tend to put their hands and other potentially contaminated objects

into their mouths.

4. Supervise hand washing for small children to make sure that it is adequate. See

our CDC website for proper hand washing guidelines:

5. Always wash your hands with soap and water after touching chickens or anything

in their environment. If soap and water are not available, use an alcohol based

hand sanitizer. Bacteria on your hands can be easily transferred to objects and

other people in your home.

6. Wash contaminated items with hot soapy water or with a mild bleach solution.

7. Do not eat or drink around your chickens.

8. Keep chickens away from food preparation areas.

9. Do not wash items from chicken coops like water and food dishes in the kitchen

sink.

10. Do not allow chickens to roam freely around the house.

11. Frequently clean the area where chickens are kept.

12. Visit your physician if you experience abdominal pain, fever, and/or diarrhea.